#33 of 46 Pigeon Forge Restaurants

Old Mill Creamery

See all photos (7 Photos)
Find Your Favorite Sweet Treats at Old Mill Creamery
Local Expert's Rating:
4.5 / 5
The Bottom Line:

Old Mill Creamery is an updated ice cream parlor that serves up scoops of classic and signature flavors in sugar cones, bowls, shakes, and more.

- The SmokyMountains.com Local Expert Team

Whether you’re looking for a little indulgence or you simply can’t ignore your sweet tooth any longer, you need to make a trip to Old Mill Creamery in Pigeon Forge. This ice cream parlor offers a mix of classic flavors, signature creations, cookies, sundaes, shakes, and more. With an extensive menu of flavors, it’s easy to find a favorite for everyone in your family.

Plenty of Classics
Walk up to the ice cream bar at the Old Mill Creamery, and you’ll immediately notice a menu full of classic flavors you love. For a truly traditional ice cream cone, consider the Simply Sweet Vanilla, Black Lantern Chocolate, or Smoky Mountain Strawberry. Other classic flavors include peanut butter, mint chocolate chip, rocky road, cookies-n-cream, chocolate chip cookie dough, and southern butter pecan.

Unique Specialty Creations
Along with classic flavors, Old Mill Creamery also offers up some signature creations you won’t find anywhere else. These include the oat mill cream pie, which comes with chunky pieces of homemade oatmeal cream pies made from thick cut rolled table oats from The Old Mill. There’s also the whiskey ribbon, which is a decadent treat laced with moonshine from the Old Forge Distillery, and homemade fudge from The Old Mill Candy Kitchen.

Served the Way You Want It
After you decide which flavor of ice cream you’re interested in, your next decision is how you want it served. With plenty of options available, you might have a hard time choosing. You have your traditional cup or sugar cone, but you also have unique options, like a cake cone, waffle cone, or waffle bowl. Additionally, you can choose to have your ice cream served in a shake, malt, or float.

Fresh and Local Ingredients
While there are many reasons people love to travel to Old Mill Creamery for something sweet, perhaps the biggest is the care the ice cream parlor puts into its creations. Whether it’s grains from The Old Mill, spirits from the Old Forge Distillery, candies from The Old Mill Candy Kitchen, or ingredients directly from the nearby farms, the flavors of ice cream at the Old Mill Creamery incorporate fresh elements to create a taste that’s special.

Other Desserts Available
While the homemade ice cream at Old Mill Creamery is a delicious treat on a warm day, if you’re in the mood for something else, there are other desserts available. You can pick up some homemade cookies, ice cream sandwiches, brownies, and more. You’ll also find a great selection of hot and cold beverages.

Savor something sweet and delicious when you stop by Old Mill Creamery for a scoop or two of your favorite ice cream flavors.

Insider’s Tip:

  • If you feel like you need to burn off some of the calories from your ice cream, Old Mill Creamery is just part of a complex of shops and restaurants in Old Mill Square for you to explore. In addition, Patriot Park is within walking distance.