#0 of 77 Gatlinburg Restaurants

Slice Pizza Bakery

Slice Pizza Bakery – Savor New York Style Pizza in the Heart of Gatlinburg, TN
Written by: Jasmin Diaz
Local Expert's Rating:
4 / 5
The Bottom Line:

When nothing else will do but authentic New York-style pizza, set your sights on the Slice Pizza Bakery. Although they’re located in the heart of Gatlinburg, this pizzeria proudly creates ooey, gooey, utterly foldable slices that are larger than life. You can get any toppings you’d like, too, although their pepperoni and extra cheese is a fan favorite.

- The SmokyMountains.com Local Expert Team

Are you on the hunt for New York-style pizza done right in the heart of Gatlinburg, TN? If so, look no further than Slice Pizza Bakery, located in the arcade at the Gatlinburg Space Needle. At this popular pizzeria, they go big on the flavor and even bigger on their huge, foldable slices. You won’t believe how mind-blowingly huge each slice is as you pick it up and bite into the cheesy deliciousness.

The magic starts with their freshly made pizza dough. They whip up batch after batch each day to keep their loyal patrons well-fed whenever they come in. When you put in your order, their skilled pizza chef hand tosses the dough until it’s perfectly thin and ready for toppings. The sheer elasticity of the dough ensures it gets thin enough for its signature slices without tearing apart while flying through the air.

Once the dough is ready, the chef piles on the sauce and toppings of your choice. Their pepperoni and extra cheese pizza is a fan favorite, but there is also Hawaiian, New York White, and Veggie Pizza if you prefer. You can add even more toppings to their base pies if you wish, but it’ll cost extra for each one. Prefer to dream up your own combinations? Just ask to build your pizza from the ground up.

You’re welcome to buy their pizzas whole in 13-inch and 16-inch sizes, but most people come through the doors for a single slice. At Slice Pizza Bakery each slice equals the same amount of pizza as a personal pan, making it difficult to even pack two away. Although pizza is the name of that game, that’s not all they have. You can also get sub sandwiches, wings, and salad galore.

You’re welcome to start your meal with an appetizer, like cheesy bread sticks, or just order up your favorite starter to enjoy with a beer. Their beer offerings include Stella Artois, Blue Moon, and Angry Orchard. Prefer non-alcoholic beverages? They have fountain drinks, sweet tea, hot chocolate, and bottled water.

If you’re sticking around for a full meal, expect a long wait for your order to arrive at the table. Their team works fast, but everything is handmade when you order it, so it’s difficult to whip it out of the kitchen in just a few minutes. So, kick back and relax at your preferred table or try out some of the games in the arcade.

You absolutely need to try these menu items at Slice Pizza Bakery:

Sidewinders Basket
The Sidewinders Basket is a great way to start your meal. To create this popular appetizer, the chef simply spiral cuts potatoes and then deep fries them to perfection. A generous sprinkle of salt finishes them off right, and you can ask for whatever dipping sauce you’d like.

Meatball Sub
When you order the Meatball Sub at Slice Pizza Bakery, you’re guaranteed to enjoy bold, rich flavors from beginning to end. This entrée starts with baked Italian meatballs smothered in marinara and loaded onto French bread. Over that, they add mozzarella and parmesan cheese before melting the cheese in the oven until bubbly and golden brown.

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
If you’re going for the gold, treat yourself to the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza, for sure. This popular pie features a blend of rich cheeses paired with seasoned steak, onions, peppers, and mushrooms. Want to take the flavors to the next level? Ask to add applewood smoked bacon and jalapenos to the mix.

When you’re simply craving a sweet treat, their Apple Dessert Pizza will do the trick. Made using their signature dough, this tasty treat features apple cinnamon flavors in every last bite. If you’re in the mood for a frozen treat instead, they have soft-serve ice cream available in a cone or cup. You can even get a waffle cone for an extra charge.

Insider Tips:
-Specialty pizzas land on the menu on the regular.  To avoid missing out, ask if there’s been anything new added lately to get the inside scoop.
-Don’t forget to snap a selfie with your pizza slice before digging in. Then, post it on social media to join other happy customers in showing the world their favorite pizza.