Gatlinburg Pizza Guide: Your Top Spots for Scrumptious Pizza Pies

When you’re in the mood for rich sauce, melty cheese, and all your favorite toppings, only the best pizza will do. But how can you possibly find the most scrumptious pizza pies in the Gatlinburg, Tennessee, region? With help from this guide, of course! Simply take a look at these fantastic pizza shops, and then get your order on the books, so you can chow down in no time flat.

Big Daddy’s Pizzeria

At Big Daddy’s Pizzeria, all the magic happens right inside the brick oven where wood-fired flames crisp up your pizzas to perfection. Even more spectacularly, they make all their dough by hand before shaping it into whatever size pie you desire. Their homemade sauces and ultra-fresh toppings then bring it all together to treat you to pizza done right.

Although you might be tempted to race straight to their pies, their appetizers are well worth considering. The Dough Daddies, in particular, give you a taste of their artisan yeast rolls, which are smothered in olive oil, garlic, and parmesan cheese.

Beyond that, they have classic and specialty pies plus a sausage crust option for those who need to skip the sugar. You can even go with a sandwich or salad if you wish. Just be sure to save room for their dessert because their Cannoli and Tropical Cheesecake are out of this world delicious.

Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria

Best Italian Café & Pizzeria sticks with traditional ingredients and cooking methods to serve up comfort food everyone will love. The only unconventional thing on their menu is their calzones, which are made larger than life to ensure you walk away feeling wholly satisfied with your meal. Although pizza is definitely at the heart of all they do, their menu goes way beyond those pies to include pasta, lasagna, and other Italian favorites.

Despite all the options, you’ll likely find yourself coming back to the pizza and calzones time and time again. They make their pizza with a New York style thin crust, tomato sauce, and all the ingredients you could want. Of all their amazing options, The Best Deluxe Pizza is the talk of the town with its pepperoni, sausage, beef, and a whole lot of veggies.

Mellow Mushroom

When you pop into the Mellow Mushroom, you just know that your meal is going to exceed your every expectation. They handmake all of their pizza dough, assemble each pie with loving care, and then bake it all upright in their stone oven.

No matter what pizza you’re in the mood to eat, start off your meal with their Cheese Bread, Pretzel Bites, or Spinach Artichoke Dip. While you nosh on any of those options, you can start mentally assembling your pizza with all the toppings you could ever imagine, including:

  • Applewood Smoked Bacon
  • Buffalo Tofu
  • Jerk Chicken
  • Tempeh
  • Avocado
  • Caramelized Onions
  • Peppadew Peppers
  • Blue Cheese Crumbles
  • MontAmore

If all those options are just too much, order one of their signature recipes instead, like the Holy Shiitake, Funky Q Chicken, or Mighty Meat. In addition to their classic pizza pies, they can make yours 100% vegan or gluten-free if you wish.

Ski Mountain Pizza

Ski Mountain Pizza makes it their mission to serve up New York style pizza from the comfort of their Gatlinburg lodge. Each morning, they make their own dough, sauces, and salad dressings plus prep all their other ingredients for the day. Then, they hand-assemble every pizza and other dishes to suit your every expectation.

With Garlic Bread Sticks, Mozzarella Cheese Sticks, and Meatballs as options, their starters are always a great way to kick off your meal. Then, you can build your own pizzas and calzones or go with their specialty options. If you’re not sure what to order, you can never go wrong with the Barbecue, Mountain Man, or Veggie pizzas.

Taste of Italy

When you want all the most authentic pizza flavors served with a smile, the Taste of Italy will come through in a big way. Their huge menu of Italian favorites lets you build your meal from the ground up any way you’d like.

You can whet your appetite with their Mussels, Fried Mushrooms, or Buffalo Shrimp to start. After that, you might want to go straight for the pizza or pair your pies with pasta and salad of all kinds.

On their menu, they have many specialty pizza flavors to choose from, including Margherita Pizza with tomatoes, basil, and buffalo mozzarella. If you want to build your own pizza, just select either regular or gluten-free crust in your preferred size, and then start piling on the toppings.

Slice Pizza Bakery

If you like New York style pizza, you absolutely have to try the pies whipped up at the Slice Pizza Bakery. But first, get settled in with a taste of their delectable starters, like the pretzel bites, cinnamon sticks, or sidewinders basket.

Only then will you be ready to turn your attention to their specialty pizza flavors, including their phenomenal Philly Cheese Steak Pizza and Pulled Pork Barbecue Pizzas. If you’d like to take your order up a notch, get the Wing Combo for zesty wings, a side salad, and drink alongside your pie.

Even though it might be difficult, leave a little bit of room in your belly for their soft serve waffle cone. No matter which flavors you choose, the icy cold ice cream serves as the perfect way to end your meal.

Even if you land on a fantastic pizza shop the first time around, give it another whirl by selecting a different spot on this list. As you try out each one, you’ll have a chance to enjoy all the best pizza in Gatlinburg, Tennessee. Then, you can go again and again to sample their various menu items and figure out which ones perfectly hit the spot.